Performance Management Blog

Managers – Biggest Contributors or Biggest Problem?

An outstanding article got published today by Jim Clifton, the CEO of Gallup. If you have not noticed the transition of this company over the years, it has moved from its stereotyped base as a “polling organization” to one that is tightly focused on issues of workplace improvement. This article by Mr. Clifton appeared in LinkedIn and is mindblowing.

Jim CliftonYou can find the article here:

The data — 1,390,941 workers compiled into one database — says that of the 100,000,000 or so full time workers in the US, 30,000,000  (30%) are engaged and inspired at work and 20,000,000 (20%) employees  are actively disengaged. It’s that old Henny Youngman line, “…Take my wife. Please!” reframed to, “…Take my boss… Please!” in the case of the 20 million who – again – are ACTIVELY dis-engaged, un-involved and un-inspired.

Henny Youngman( See Henny Youngman perform on Ed Sullivan (1966). )

The point that Youngman makes is that he wishes things could be different (he is actually joking, and it is funny!). The point Jim Clifton makes is that leadership in management is a critical factor in employee motivation and performance, and that good managers are a lot different than bad bosses in how they impact the workplace and the US economy. He is not joking and nothing is funny about allowing things to simply continue the way things are…

As Clifton says,

Here is my big conclusion: A workforce of 100 million employees in America requires a 10-1 ratio of managers to teams. So, for the U.S. to be perfectly managed, it requires 10 million great supervisors and then 1 million great managers of those supervisors. Pick the right people for these roles, the ones who know best how to engage their people, and the country will rise up economically like never before.

But the problem is, given my 10-1 ratio, there are, in my estimate, only about 3 million great managers inspiring and motivating those 30 million engaged employees. That’s just not enough great leadership.

 We do NOT need 3 million great managers leading people; what we need are a few million fewer Bad Bosses un-leading them! In other posts in my blog, I discuss dis-un-engagement and the issues surrounding the unmotivated middle of the workforce. We can impact them in many ways. In my post about the seemingly unmotivated, I discuss my thinking on what we can do differently to make improvements. It is not rocket science. In my post about Pogo, it is about this simple concept:

“We have met the enemy and he is us.”

Like  Mr. Clifton, I believe that we must make changes in how people are managed. His approach is focused on engagement, and so is mine. He takes the position that the three key issues of importance, based on their survey results are:

1.     At work,  I have the opportunity to do what I do best every day. This is the single-best survey item you can ask an employee. If they score high on this, it means they have been assigned a job for which they have the talent to excel. Mastering this begins with companies identifying employees’ strengths and putting them in the right roles.

2.     There is someone at work who encourages my development.

3.     At work, my opinions seem to count.

I take the position that most people are un-engaged and un-involved and that every manager and supervisor needs to focus in DIS-un-engagement and the implementation of ideas — Engagimentation. It is a simple concept of facilitating ideas in the workplace and then working to implement those ideas by better managing perceived and actual roadblocks. The tools are simple and the approach is straightforward.

Reality of how things work SWs One

and the possibilities that exist for making the workplace a better place:

Rainbow Wagon green 70


For the FUN of It!

Dr. Scott SimmermanDr. Scott Simmerman is a designer of team building games and organization improvement tools. Managing Partner of Performance Management Company since 1984, he is an experienced presenter and consultant.

Connect with Scott on Google+ – you can reach Scott at

Follow Scott’s posts on Pinterest:
Scott’s blog on Poems and Quips on Workplace Improvement is here.

<a rel=”author” href=”″ a>

Dr. Scott Simmerman

Dr. Scott Simmerman is a designer of team building games and organization improvement tools. Managing Partner of Performance Management Company since 1984, he is an experienced presenter and consultant, earning CPT and CPF credentials. -- You can reach Scott at and a detailed profile is here: -- Scott is the original designer of The Search for The Lost Dutchman's Gold Mine teambuilding game and the Square Wheels® images for organizational development.

Subscribe to the blog





  1. Workplace Motivation Improvement – Easy! | Performance Management Company Blog - [...] (see a great article posted up on data from Gallup shared by Jim Clifton) [...]
  2. Motivating People, Motivating Teams | Performance Management Company Blog - [...] differently. It is based on Gallup research and ascribed to Jim Clifton, CEO of that organization. You can view…
  3. What do you do when they do things PERFECTLY – some thoughts on team building | Performance Management Company Blog - [...] we see in statistics about workplaces (70% of people are dis-engaged and badly managed (link) and that 53% of…
  4. Improving Leadership Effectiveness = Dis-Un-Engagement | Performance Management Company Blog - […]… […]
  5. Keeping Things Simple – Involving and Engaging | Performance Management Company Blog - […] Is this because I have a biased view of supervisors, managers and executives? NO. (Well, partly). It is really…
  6. Nobody Ever Washes a Rental Car – some practical ideas about implementation, ownership and involvement | Performance Management Company Blog - […] (This is a pretty solid post around the issue above) […]
  7. Intrinsic Motivation and Engagement – Training is NOT the answer | Performance Management Company Blog - […] workplace engagement, we have a wide variety of performance based issues. Here is an article on the problem of…
  8. Puppies and Performance Improvement – Random Thoughts… | Performance Management Company Blog - […] here and here with stats on this here) and it seems to be an issue of how people are…
  9. Trust is the Residue of Promises Fulfilled – An Update | Performance Management Company Blog - […] It directly impacts morale and increases employee turnover and decreases engagement. It is an issue of management and leadership.…
  10. Decision Making, Creativity, and Implementation | Performance Management Company Blog - […] You can find Jim Clifton’s thoughts on firing a few million bad bosses here. […]
  11. Fear is The Mindkiller – Thoughts on Facilitation and Engagement | Performance Management Company Blog - […] (This is not me talking for him — see this link for what he said and how he was…
  12. If you aren’t leading and engaging, what ARE you doing? | Performance Management Company Blog - […] Jim Clifton seemed to seriously suggest that the data from his Gallup polling would suggest a realistic situation were…
  13. How Square Wheels stop The North Korea Leadership Style in any company | Performance Management Company Blog - […] from Hell” and generating more of the behaviors we see with the top performing ones. (My article here and…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like